Skip to main content
Broadview Lending powered by Barrett Financial Group
Apply
Illustrative notebook and coffee on a table, ready for planning

Comparison

HELOC vs Cash-Out Refinance

Two ways to access home equity that solve different problems. The right one often depends on your current mortgage rate.

Compare My OptionsTalk With An Advisor

HELOC

Best for

  • Keeping a low first-mortgage rate
  • Flexible, as-needed access
  • Phased projects like remodels

Advantages

  • Leaves your existing mortgage untouched
  • Pay interest only on what you draw
  • Reusable line during the draw period

Tradeoffs

  • Typically a variable rate
  • Payment can change over time

Cash-Out Refinance

Best for

  • One large, one-time need
  • Wanting a single fixed payment
  • When today's rate is similar or better

Advantages

  • One consolidated loan and payment
  • Often a fixed rate

Tradeoffs

  • Replaces your first mortgage and its rate
  • Resets your loan term

Questions we'd discuss

  • Is preserving your current first-mortgage rate a priority?
  • Do you need flexible access or one lump sum?
  • How long will you carry the balance?

Things to consider

  • Your current rate versus today's rates
  • Comfort with a variable rate
  • Total long-term cost, not just the payment

Keep exploring

Continue your strategy — every step here leads somewhere useful.

Related articles

HELOC vs Cash-Out Refinance

A HELOC keeps your current first mortgage in place while adding flexible access to equity. A cash-out refinance replaces your mortgage with one new loan, which can fit larger needs or one fixed payment.

Interactive guides

Would a HELOC potentially fit?

A few quick questions to help you understand whether a home equity line of credit is worth discussing — not whether you qualify.

Helpful tools

Cash-Out vs HELOC

Compare keeping your current mortgage with a HELOC against a full cash-out refinance.

Related strategies

Cash-Out Refinance | Access Your Home Equity

Access equity with one consolidated mortgage.

Start your assessment

Home Equity Strategy Experience

Start with your property, equity goal, and advisor-reviewed strategy.

Refinance

Explore whether a lower rate, shorter term, or cash-out strategy may make sense.

Here's what we'd discuss together

A strategy call isn't a sales pitch. It's a conversation about your goals — here's what we'd actually talk through.

Monthly payment comfort

Not the maximum you qualify for — the number that fits your life.

Future plans

How long you expect to stay and what's next for you.

Cash reserves

Keeping a healthy cushion after closing, not just at it.

Equity strategy

Whether to use, preserve, or grow your home equity.

Timeline

What needs to happen, and by when, to hit your goal.

Income stability

How your income is structured and documented.

Talk With A Mortgage Advisor

What Happens Next

A real advisor reviews your information — then guides you from here.

Technology prepares the conversation. People make the difference. Here is exactly what to expect after you share your goals.

  1. 01

    Complete your personalized assessment.

    Tell us about your goals, timeline, and the details that help us understand the decision in front of you.

  2. 02

    A mortgage advisor personally reviews your information.

    Our technology prepares the conversation. It never replaces it.

  3. 03

    We reach out to answer questions and discuss your options.

    You will not be handed off to a call center or left alone to interpret generic results.

  4. 04

    Together we shape the strategy that fits your goals.

    We will explain the trade-offs before recommending a loan path.

  5. 05

    If you're ready, we guide you through to closing.

    Move forward with clarity, confidence, and a real person beside you.